Your website isn’t broken, but your follow-up strategy might be. You’re generating leads, but when you call them, all you get is voicemail. Sound familiar?
If you’re wondering why your conversion rates are plummeting despite strong lead generation, the answer might be simpler than you think: your prospects aren’t ignoring you, they’re avoiding all unknown callers.
Join the conversation on LinkedIn:
Key Takeaways
- 42% of Australians now avoid answering calls from unknown numbers due to scam concerns, with even higher rates among women (47%) and Gen X (45%).
- In the US and UK, the problem is worse, with up to 87% of Americans avoiding unknown calls.
- This call avoidance effectively doubles your cost per engaged prospect if you’re relying on phone follow-up.
- Six proven strategies can dramatically improve your contact rates:
- Sending a personalized SMS before calling
- Using the triple-dial method
- Following up with additional context via SMS or email
- Implementing video messages to build trust
- Prioritizing speed-to-lead
- Switching to booked consultations instead of cold calls
The Silent Epidemic: Why Your Calls Go Unanswered
Let’s face it: cold calling has never been less effective than it is today. A recent Telstra survey revealed that 42% of Australians are now less likely to answer calls from unknown numbers due to rising scam concerns. This hesitancy increases to 47% for women and 45% for Gen X.
Geographically, Queenslanders show the most reluctance (47%), closely followed by Victorians and South Australians.
And Australia is actually doing better than other countries. In the United States, an astonishing 87% of people avoid answering calls from unknown numbers. The United Kingdom isn’t far behind, with over 60% ignoring landline calls and half refusing to answer their mobiles.
The math is brutal: If half your leads never pick up, you’ve immediately doubled your cost per engaged prospect.
Think about this from your prospect’s perspective. They visited your website and filled out a form because they were interested at that moment. But when your unknown number appears on their screen hours or days later, the context is gone. To them, it’s just another interruption—another mystery caller potentially wasting their time when they’re trying to focus on important tasks.
Why Your Lead’s Psychology Matters
Your leads aren’t rejecting you personally. They simply don’t know who you are.
That incoming call represents:
- An unknown entity
- A potential time-waster
- Another interruption in their busy day
- Possibly a scam or sales pitch they didn’t ask for
The excitement they felt when submitting the form has faded. Now your call is competing with their desire to get into “deep work” and accomplish their daily tasks.
This isn’t about lead quality—it’s about human psychology and the changing relationship people have with their phones.
Six Strategies That Actually Work
If your business relies on phone follow-up to convert leads, you need a new approach. These six strategies have been tested and proven to dramatically improve contact rates:
1. Send a Personalized SMS Before Calling
Before you pick up the phone, send a text message that includes:
- Your name
- Your company
- Why you’re calling
- When you’ll be calling
This simple courtesy provides context and significantly increases the likelihood they’ll answer. Modern smartphones (especially iPhones) will even suggest who might be calling based on previous text messages, giving you an additional advantage.
Example SMS: “Hi Sarah, it’s John from PixelRush digital marketing. You requested information about our SEO services yesterday. I’ll be calling in about 10 minutes to answer your questions. Looking forward to chatting!”
2. Use the Triple-Dial Method
This technique feels counterintuitive, but the data shows it works.
Call three times back-to-back. This pattern:
- Signals urgency (something may be wrong or important)
- Stands out from typical spam call patterns
- Creates a pattern recognition that bypasses the “unknown number” mental block
While it might feel aggressive at first, conversion data shows it can increase answer rates by up to 40% compared to single call attempts.
3. Follow Up With a Second Communication Channel
If they still don’t answer, immediately follow your call with either:
- A detailed SMS that provides context, establishes credibility, and offers a clear next step
- An email with similar information plus additional value (like a relevant resource)
The key is to make this follow-up about them, not about you. Don’t just say, “Call us back.” Give them a compelling reason to reconnect.
Example follow-up text: “Hi Tom, sorry I missed you. I wanted to discuss how we might be able to help increase your website conversion rates by 30% like we did for [similar business]. When would be a good time to chat this week?”
4. Leverage Video For Trust-Building
Nothing builds trust faster than seeing a real human being explain who they are and how they can help. This is especially powerful when the lead doesn’t know you yet.
Keep your video:
- Short (under 60 seconds)
- Personal (mention specifics about their business or inquiry)
- Casual and authentic (professional but not overly polished)
- Action-oriented (clear on what happens next)
You don’t need fancy equipment, your smartphone camera is more than adequate. The authenticity of a simple, direct video message often outperforms highly produced content.
5. Prioritize Speed-to-Lead
Research consistently shows that calling within five minutes of receiving a lead significantly improves your chance of making contact. After 30 minutes, the odds drop dramatically.
This can be challenging when leads come in outside business hours, but consider:
- Implementing an after-hours response system
- Using automation for immediate acknowledgment
- Assigning weekend or evening follow-up responsibilities
Don’t let preconceptions about “appropriate” business hours limit your growth. The fastest responder often wins the business.
6. Switch to Booked Consultations
Instead of chasing leads with cold calls, shift your strategy to scheduled consultations:
- Invite leads to book a specific time for a call or meeting
- Send automated reminders as the appointment approaches
- Create a compelling offer that makes showing up valuable to them
This approach respects their time while dramatically increasing the likelihood of meaningful contact.
Example: “Schedule a free 30-minute website audit where we’ll identify your top three conversion opportunities—guaranteed value whether you become a client or not.”
Modernizing Your Response System
If your business, especially service businesses like law firms, still relies on reception staff making single call attempts to convert leads, it’s time to update your process.
The traditional follow-up model was built for a world where people answered their phones. That world no longer exists.
A modern lead response system should:
- Leverage multiple communication channels
- Provide context before expecting engagement
- Respect the lead’s time and preferences
- Build trust through transparency and consistency
Remember: People aren’t deliberately ignoring you. They simply don’t recognize your number, and in 2024, that’s enough reason for most prospects to let your call go to voicemail.
Moving Forward: Adapt or Lose Leads
The businesses that will thrive in this new environment aren’t necessarily those with the best products or services, but those who adapt to changing communication preferences.
This isn’t about being pushy or employing manipulative sales tactics. It’s about recognizing a fundamental shift in how people interact with their phones and adjusting your approach accordingly.
By implementing these six strategies, you can dramatically improve your contact rates without increasing your marketing spend, effectively doubling your ROI just by changing how you follow up with the leads you already have.
Your prospects want to hear from you. They’re just waiting to know who you are first.
